Stable funding source needed for schools
Oct 19, 2009 | 1297 views | 12 12 comments | 8 8 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Like him or hate him, the head of the state’s powerful teacher union, Paul Hubbert, is right when he says Alabama needs a more stable funding source for education.

So what else is new? Alabama has been dancing the education two step for years — one step forward, two steps back — every time there is a downturn in the economy.

That’s what happens when officials tie the bulk of funding to taxes that are subject to peaks and valleys, like sales tax. Property tax is a more stable source, but there is a negative knee jerk reaction guaranteed whenever the subject is raised, let alone the taxes.

Truth is, Alabama continues to have the cheapest property tax in the nation. And much needed programs, like the Alabama Math, Science and Technology Initiative can’t even get the funding it needs to help move state students forward because the funds aren’t there.

Explain to students struggling through Math and Science or who cannot get access to a computer that the culprit is the downturn in the economy and not the people who refuse to invest in our children’s future.

Having a hard time making that argument? It should come as no surprise. It just doesn’t add up against the backdrop of the needs in classrooms around this state.

There should be no difference in a classroom in Mountain Brook and a classroom in the Black Belt, but there is. And the most significant difference is the investment made in education.

Ten times over the past 30 years — one third of the time — Alabama schools have suffered under proration. And budget cuts do not bode well for Alabama’s students.

While the issue of reforming Alabama’s tax system to provide adequate and stable funding for the state’s school will likely come up again in the next legislative session, it will not be successful until a majority of the leaders in this state step forward to make it so.

Let’s hope they will for the sake of Alabama’s children.

Comments
(12)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Steve Terrell
|
October 20, 2009
BG - You're wasting your breath (or your typing fingers) if you think that gambling or buying beer on Sunday is anywhere in the near future for Alabama. Actually, it kind of reminds me of that Mel Brooks movie where Moses dropped one of the tablets and it broke; that must have been where the "anti drinking / gambling" commandments were written.

Jim - I like your idea of the averaging; that's certainly one way to work the 1 to 2 year economic downturn into the equation. What the hell do we know though; we're only intelligent.

st
Jim Hethcox
|
October 20, 2009
For starters, How about an educational budget based on an average of the previous five years instead of one that is based on so-called "anticipated revenue" (read that as pie-in-the-sky numberss aimed at getting re-elected).
Steve Terrell
|
October 20, 2009
Someone mentioned standardized testing. I'm almost as opposed to it as I am corporal punishment, homework and gifted programs. This book will really open your eyes:

The Case Against Standardized Testing: Raising the Scores, Ruining the Schools - the author is Alfie Kohn

Libertarian4life
|
October 20, 2009
Dear Educateme,

It's pretty easy. Instead of taking tax dollars and giving them to the fed's to give to schools, you take tax dollars and give them to parent (vouchers) they then choose what school to spend the voucher at. For example, the gov gives out food stamps they don't own grocery stores. And BTW I didn't vote for Bush twice. Vouchers have been around for a long time. It's based on capitalism. I recommend "The Worm In the Apple." If you truely care about education.
INTUNE
|
October 20, 2009
Every citizen in Alabama should read, Alabama's Public Education Dilemma: Does Funding Influence Outcomes? Researched and prepared by John R.Hill Ph.D of Alabama Policy Institute. This is a real eye opener for all those who believe you accomplish education reform by throwing more money into the mix. Real data and good research. Teacher competency; evaulauation of academic inputs and outputs. Merit pay for teachers is a move in the right direction and not years of service. Tenure needs to go to protect the able and willing teachers and get rid of the underachieving. The good should be rewarded and the others need to have remedial plans drawn for them with a short timeline to get up to par. Remember, if an underachieving teacher is teaching your child, guess who loses.
EducateMe
|
October 20, 2009
Mr. Libertarian4life, how do suppose those vouchers be paid for? Are they free? Come on now, you want to give each family a voucher to do what? Explain exactly how this "cure-all" voucher system actually works and quit respewing George Bush's ideas, the man is not in government anymore, his days and ideas are gone. You give a voucher that is worth $x,xxx amount of dollars to each family and they give it to the school of their choice, or some idiotic idea along those lines? The State controls these vouchers? Those vouchers are paid for by the measly taxes Alabamians currently pay? Come on now... that's exactly how public education is funded, the State gives each system money from our taxes. Same system, but you call it a "voucher system" and everything is fixed?
Hank Shiver
|
October 20, 2009
Amazing!!! The more illiterate the writer, the more he or she is opposed to supporting education.
Libertarian4life
|
October 20, 2009
So let me get this straight..we are supposed to spend MORE on education and continue to get less in the form of test scores?? this is a ridiculous business model. the facts are we spend TOO MUCH on education. the gov has a monopoly on education on 3 levels. teachers are overpaid. Solutions: vouchers for all parents. Null and void all CBA's. Abolish the NEA. Ban tenure. Don't believe anything a union represenative says and quite frankly enact the opposite of whatever they want.
RS3
|
October 20, 2009
This isn't necessarily research, but I can pass along some additional information. We just moved to South Carolina, and the property taxes on our automobiles were double what we were used to paying in Alabama. One difference I found helpful in stomaching the additional taxes, though, is an itemization on the tag receipt. This allows me to see how many dollars of the tax went to schools, how many dollars went to the library, etc., so I can see where I'm doing my part and receiving specific services in return.

We're renting for now, but from what I have seen, property tax on housing here appears to be slightly higher than Alabama. I did talk with family members in Georgia once about property tax, and property tax on housing in GA was a little more than twice as much as what I paid in AL for a comparable value home.
Darryl Davis
|
October 20, 2009
Look at the following words from the above article and pay close attention to was is being said. ; "Property tax is a more stable source, but there is a negative knee jerk reaction guaranteed whenever the subject is raised, let alone the taxes.

Truth is, Alabama continues to have the cheapest property tax in the nation. And much needed programs, like the Alabama Math, Science and Technology Initiative can’t even get the funding it needs to help move state students forward because the funds aren’t there. "

This is propaganda to aclimate the public to be prepared for double and maybe even triple property taxes. People are being forclosed on now in record numbers so why not raise property taxes so that the rest will lose their homes and land. Open up your billfolds and surrender your land and homes because the government needs it all for the sake of the " children" (playing on people's heartsrtings".) Take note of the last sentence in the above article.:"Let’s hope they will for the sake of Alabama’s children". If people do not take a stand on this issue then a lot of people will be living in government housing and or in the woods.Things are bad now but they are about to get worse.
Steve Terrell
|
October 20, 2009
Right on target DH. Great editorial!
J. Morgan
|
October 20, 2009
I always hear we have the lowest property tax around and i guess it must be true, but have your checked into the taxes we pay for our car tags, id bet its the highest in America. Before we just say , oh our property taxes are so low, maybe we should explore who is paying what. Im all for PUBLIC education but Mr Hubbards numbers do not compute with me when the salaries it takes to run his offices would probably pay the entire public school budget for Alabama. Please research the car tags and let me know what you find out, you might be surprised.

Post Your Stuff
Daily Home comment section
Aug 28 09 - 01:41 AM

Should The Daily Home require readers to register before posting comments?